[Analysis] Ethical Dilemmas in Banking – Meaning | Examples | How to Resolve Them
- Blog|FEMA & Banking|
- 9 Min Read
What makes a choice an ethical dilemma, where bankers meet one, and how to work through it with a step-by-step method, the Josephson Institute’s three-step model and Lynn Paine’s moral compass.
- By Taxmann
- |
- Last Updated on 16 November, 2026

Table of Contents
- What is an ethical dilemma?
- Why do bankers face ethical dilemmas?
- Which dilemmas come up in a bank?
- How can an ethical dilemma be resolved?
- What is the Josephson Institute’s three-step model?
- What is Lynn Paine’s moral compass?
- How does the Golden Rule help?
- Quick answers
1. What is an ethical dilemma?
When one option is plainly right and the other plainly wrong, the choice is relatively simple. Truth over a lie, modesty over arrogance, peace over violence: few people would hesitate.
An ethical dilemma is different. It arises when two courses of action both carry moral weight, so that each looks right from its own point of view. It is not a disagreement between right and wrong but a clash between two rights. The decision-maker has to work out which right is more right.
Take a product division that has become unprofitable. If it is kept going, losses mount and it may become a burden on other units. If it is closed, the people who work there lose their jobs. Either choice can be defended. Dilemmas get harder still when the law, religion or moral theory offers no guidance.
A situation is an ethical dilemma when three things are present:
- a real conflict of values among different interests;
- alternatives that are equally justifiable; and
- significant consequences for the stakeholders involved.
| Point | Right versus wrong | Right versus right (an ethical dilemma) |
|---|---|---|
| What the choice involves | One option is plainly wrong | Both options carry moral weight |
| Examples | Truth or a lie; modesty or arrogance | Trust or loyalty; justice or mercy |
| How hard it is | Relatively simple | Hard, because each option can be defended |
For an organisation, a bigger dilemma comes when economic goals pull against social performance, and resources have to be divided between the two.
2. Why do bankers face ethical dilemmas?
Banks can work well only when the public trusts them, and any bank, however well placed, meets moral dilemmas in the normal course of business. Many of its decisions are not between right and wrong but between right and less right.
Three things make these choices harder for a banker:
- Many stakeholders. A decision affects the bank’s revenue, costs and profits, and also its customers, colleagues, investors and the public. Ethical decision-making for bankers has to weigh all of them.
- Clashing values. For a professional, a dilemma comes from a conflict between personal and organisational values, or with the values of society. Conflicts of interest are one form, for example a choice of whose transaction comes first, the customer’s or the employer’s. Others involve a threat to independence and objectivity, or money received once a deal is done.
- Group decisions. In an organisation, dilemmas are often settled by committees and groups, on business goals rather than individual ones. Personal ethics can then clash with the ethics of the group, or of one powerful person, and employees may even be taught to ignore an issue they think is unethical.
The answer is not to give in and go along with management or the group. Open and honest discussion of the issue is important to sound ethical decisions.
3. Which dilemmas come up in a bank?
Dilemmas can arise at many stages of serving a customer. They come up in opening an account and applying KYC norms, in charging interest, and in disbursing and monitoring loans. They also come up in due diligence on credit proposals and in applying provisioning norms. At each stage, staff are expected to follow ethical principles in spite of pressure from inside or outside the bank. Where a dilemma exists, they should refer to the law, the code of ethics or internal guidelines.
| Situation | The pull | What is expected |
|---|---|---|
| Selling a product | A sales target tied to financial or non-financial incentives | Do not push a product that does not fit the customer’s need, profile or risk appetite |
| Explaining charges | The fear that full disclosure will lose the sale | Tell the customer about all charges; do not hide implicit charges |
| Appraising a loan | Bending the process for a selfish motive, to accept or reject a proposal | Follow the laid down process; when in doubt, consult senior management or the compliance and legal officers instead of acting alone |
| Wrongdoing by colleagues | Loyalty to the organisation and the group | Speaking up is ethical where it saves the organisation from causing serious harm to the public or from breaking the law |
Some dilemmas are personal. One of the book’s cases asks whether you would give a positive reference to an irresponsible employee, simply to help him move to a job in a private bank.
4. How can an ethical dilemma be resolved?
Start by looking beyond a win-lose frame. People tend to see a dilemma as a contest in which one side must lose, and that narrows their thinking. With a full and factual understanding of the situation, and some ingenuity, a solution may be found in which everyone gains.
A practical sequence of steps:
- Recognise that there is a moral issue.
- Identify who will be affected by the decision, and your own role.
- Gather the facts, including the order in which events happened.
- Apply the right-versus-wrong test: how would the problem look from the other side of the fence?
- Apply the right-versus-right test, such as trust against loyalty or justice against mercy.
- Work through three approaches: ends-based thinking (whatever does the greatest good for the greatest number), rule-based thinking (follow the rule strictly) and care-based thinking (treat others as you would like them to treat you).
- Check that your approach is reasonable and persuasive.
- Look for a third way out.
- Decide and act.
- Revisit the decision and reflect on it.
Two sets of factors shape how a manager handles a dilemma. Organisational factors include the bank’s policies and procedures, its culture and shared values, its structure and hierarchy, and the attitude of top management. A clear policy narrows the choice: if the bank expressly bars bribes, kickbacks and gifts to win business, the manager knows which way to go. Individual factors include how narrowly the manager sees the job, his or her background, and personal values.
Sometimes the answer is the lesser of two evils, since a perfect answer will not always exist. The question then is whether you can live with the outcome. Joseph L. Badaracco Jr. describes this in Defining Moments as “sleep-test ethics”: someone who has made the right choice can sleep soundly afterwards, and a decision that keeps troubling you deserves another look.
5. What is the Josephson Institute’s three-step model?
Ethical decisions were traditionally judged on four factors: the outcome sought, the means used, the motive, and the likely consequences. If any one of them is unacceptable, the decision is unethical. For bankers this is no longer enough, because a decision must also account for its effect on customers, colleagues, the bank, investors and the public.
The Josephson Institute of Ethics developed a character-based decision-making model for everyday decisions and for ethical dilemmas. It has three steps:
- Consider everyone affected. Every decision should reflect concern for the interests and well-being of all stakeholders. The principle behind this step is the Golden Rule: help when you can, and avoid harm when you can.
- Put ethical values first. Ethical values and principles always take precedence over non-ethical ones. The danger point is a clash between what a person wants, or feels he or she needs, and an ethical principle. If rationalisation begins, that clash is probably present.
- Depart from a principle only to uphold another. It is ethically proper to violate an ethical principle only when that is clearly necessary to advance another true ethical principle. The decision-maker’s conscience must judge that this will produce the greater good in the long run.
When every workable option means giving up one ethical value for another, the decision-maker should act to create the greatest good and the least harm for the greatest number of people.
6. What is Lynn Paine’s moral compass?
Harvard ethics professor Lynn Paine offers a four-part “moral compass” to make sure ethical considerations are factored into every organisational decision. Each part is a lens that brings one side of the situation into focus. Used together, the lenses make it easier to judge the ethical content of even routine decisions.
IIBF’s courseware adds three more lenses for bankers, which makes the compass easier still to use.
| Lens | Question to ask | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Does the action serve a worthwhile purpose? | Lynn Paine |
| Principle | Is it consistent with the relevant principles? | Lynn Paine |
| People | Does it respect the legitimate claims of the people likely to be affected? | Lynn Paine |
| Power | Do we have the power to take this decision? | Lynn Paine |
| Prescription | Does it breach any of the bank’s policies, a regulation or the law? | Added for bankers |
| Public | Could I share it with the media tomorrow? | Added for bankers |
| Person | Am I setting a good example for others? | Added for bankers |
These lenses help to build ethics into daily decisions and to reframe a difficult situation so that all parties can benefit. Which framework a bank uses matters less than using one: its approach to decisions should be thorough and systematic.
7. How does the Golden Rule help?
The Golden Rule, also called the ethic of reciprocity, asks people to treat others as they would like to be treated themselves: with tolerance, consideration and compassion. It also means treating those junior to you the way you would want your seniors to treat you.
Its appeal is that it is universal. It draws on human feeling and experience, and it makes a person think from the other side and imagine how others might feel. For moral decisions, it is a simple and transparent starting point. Versions of it appear in almost every religion and culture, including Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Christianity, Islam, Judaism and Confucianism.
Three golden rules of ethics express the same idea:
- Do not do anything to others that would harm you if it were done to you.
- Do to others whatever you would want them to do to you.
- Do not do to others what you would not want done to you.
These rules give a screening test for what an organisation treats as its core values. They also run through the methods above. The first step of the Josephson model rests on the Golden Rule, and care-based thinking asks you to treat others as you would like them to treat you.
The rule has a limit. Not everyone thinks, acts or believes as you do. A person who would return a lost wallet cannot assume that a stranger would do the same for them.
8. Quick answers
What is an ethical dilemma?
A situation in which a person has to choose between two actions that both seem morally right. It is a clash between two rights, not a disagreement between right and wrong.
What is an example of an ethical dilemma in banking?
A banker chasing a sales target tied to incentives may be tempted to sell a product that does not suit the customer’s need or risk appetite. Another is whether to report wrongdoing by colleagues who are also friends.
Is every hard choice an ethical dilemma?
No. A choice between right and wrong, such as truth or a lie, is not a dilemma. A dilemma needs a real conflict of values, equally justifiable alternatives and significant consequences for stakeholders.
How do you resolve an ethical dilemma?
Recognise the moral issue, identify who is affected, gather the facts, and test the options as right versus wrong and right versus right. Then weigh ends-based, rule-based and care-based thinking, look for a third way, decide, act, and later reflect on the decision.
What are the three steps of the Josephson model?
First, consider the interests and well-being of everyone affected. Second, put ethical values ahead of non-ethical ones. Third, depart from an ethical principle only when it is clearly necessary to advance another true ethical principle.
What is Lynn Paine’s moral compass?
A four-part approach to decisions built on four lenses: purpose, principle, people and power. IIBF’s courseware adds three more for bankers: prescription, public and person.
What is the Golden Rule?
Treat others as you would like to be treated yourself. Also called the ethic of reciprocity, it appears in some form in almost every religion and culture.
Ethical dilemmas are covered in Unit 5 of Ethics in Banking, the courseware of the Indian Institute of Banking & Finance (IIBF) for its Certificate Course in Ethics in Banking (2026 Edition, published by Taxmann). The unit moves from the Golden Rule and Kohlberg’s stages of moral judgement to the Josephson model and the moral compass, and ends with short cases for discussion. Unit 7 takes up the dilemmas of bank marketing.
Where a dilemma turns on a rule, bank staff are expected to refer to the law, the code of ethics or internal guidelines. Banking Acts and Rules, and circulars and notifications, are on Taxmann.com | Research, FEMA, Banking & Insurance.
Related reading: the role of ethics in the life of a chartered accountant · ICAI’s revised Code of Ethics in three volumes · insider trading and whistle-blowing.
More in this series: ethics in banking: meaning, principles and challenges · PIDPI and whistleblowing in banks · code of ethics vs code of conduct · white-collar crime and corruption in banking · business ethics in banking · work ethics in banks · marketing ethics in banking · CSR and ESG in banking · the Satyam scam and bank failures · conflict of interest in banks · data ethics in banking.
Disclaimer: The content/information published on the website is only for general information of the user and shall not be construed as legal advice. While the Taxmann has exercised reasonable efforts to ensure the veracity of information/content published, Taxmann shall be under no liability in any manner whatsoever for incorrect information, if any.

Taxmann Publications has a dedicated in-house Research & Editorial Team. This team consists of a team of Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries, and Lawyers. This team works under the guidance and supervision of editor-in-chief Mr Rakesh Bhargava.
The Research and Editorial Team is responsible for developing reliable and accurate content for the readers. The team follows the six-sigma approach to achieve the benchmark of zero error in its publications and research platforms. The team ensures that the following publication guidelines are thoroughly followed while developing the content:
- The statutory material is obtained only from the authorized and reliable sources
- All the latest developments in the judicial and legislative fields are covered
- Prepare the analytical write-ups on current, controversial, and important issues to help the readers to understand the concept and its implications
- Every content published by Taxmann is complete, accurate and lucid
- All evidence-based statements are supported with proper reference to Section, Circular No., Notification No. or citations
- The golden rules of grammar, style and consistency are thoroughly followed
- Font and size that’s easy to read and remain consistent across all imprint and digital publications are applied


CA | CS | CMA