[Analysis] Satyam Scam and Bank Failures – Lessons for Bankers | PMC Bank | Silicon Valley Bank | LIBOR

  • Blog|FEMA & Banking|
  • 11 Min Read

What went wrong in the Satyam scam, at Enron, in the global financial crisis, at PMC Bank and Silicon Valley Bank, and in the LIBOR scandal, and the lessons each case holds for bankers.

  • By Taxmann
  • |
  • Last Updated on 16 November, 2026

Satyam Scam and Bank Failures

The Satyam scam was a corporate accounting fraud at Satyam Computer Services, then one of India’s leading IT companies. It came to light in January 2009: the company’s revenue, profits and cash had been inflated for years, and much of the cash in its books did not exist. Its independent directors and auditors had missed the warning signs. Ethics in Banking sets it beside bank failures and scandals: PMC Bank hid its exposure to one borrower group, Silicon Valley Bank mismanaged its risks, and Barclays misreported LIBOR.

Table of Contents

  1. What was the Satyam scam?
  2. What went wrong at Enron and in the global financial crisis?
  3. Why did PMC Bank fail?
  4. Why did Silicon Valley Bank collapse?
  5. What was the LIBOR scandal?
  6. What lessons do these failures hold for bankers?
  7. Quick answers

1. What was the Satyam scam?

Satyam Computer Services was one of India’s leading IT companies. In January 2009, it emerged that its accounts had been falsified for years.

The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) later set out the scale. Over five years, Satyam had overstated its revenue, income and cash balances by more than US$1 billion. More than 6,000 fake invoices were created, with bogus bank statements to show them as paid. The fictitious cash and cash-related balances came to half the company’s total assets. Satyam agreed to pay the SEC a US$10 million penalty, and its former auditors were sanctioned too.

There were warning signs before the fraud came out. Satyam announced plans to buy significant stakes in an infrastructure company and a real estate company. Investors objected, the plans were called off, and the episode raised questions about the company’s corporate governance. Independent directors resigned, and a whistle-blower alerted a board member to the financial misrepresentation.

Read as a case study in ethics, Satyam is a failure of oversight:

  • Weak governance: the corporate governance mechanism was too weak to monitor the actions, policies and decisions taken at the company.
  • Unclear role of independent directors: they did not discover the fraud and manipulation, and they overlooked the large cash balance in the books.
  • Auditors: they, too, overlooked the financial irregularities.
  • No transparency: the financial disclosures were not transparent, and the cash and bank balances were fake.

Its lessons apply to any bank. Every fraud starts small, so regular checks for inaccuracies should be routine and even a minor discrepancy is worth investigating. A scandal also hurts a whole industry: after Satyam, regulators scrutinised other players and investors grew sceptical. Top managers should be chosen for their credibility. And when one person combines the chairman’s and chief executive’s roles, the checks that audits rely on can weaken.

2. What went wrong at Enron and in the global financial crisis?

Enron began as a gas pipeline company in the United States. It grew as natural gas and electricity markets opened up, and became a major developer and operator of power plants, pipelines and energy projects worldwide. Its revenue rose to US$100.8 billion in 2000, and it entered 2001 as the seventh-largest company in the US.

Its managers were extremely aggressive about growth. Authority was concentrated in a few hands, and managerial accountability was poor. The company diversified rapidly, from a gas distribution company into an energy major, and then into non-core businesses such as broadband networks and bandwidth trading.

The problems came to light after a senior executive raised concerns about accounting discrepancies and inflated financial statements. Large liabilities had been kept off the books in special purpose vehicles backed by Enron’s own shares. Towards the end of 2001, large borrowings fell due that Enron could not repay, and it filed for bankruptcy on 2 December 2001. Its share price, about US$90 in August 2000, was 26 cents by the end of November 2001.

The auditor, Arthur Andersen, lost its professional credibility, and its client base suffered too. The book draws three lessons from Enron:

  • unethical accounting and misleading financial statements cannot deliver higher ambitions, and heavy pressure on staff to hit targets only breeds wrongful practices;
  • unfair practices and poor transparency should be avoided, because only sound strategy brings success in the long run;
  • regular audits can catch a problem early, but poor ethical literacy across an organisation lets problems grow.

The global financial crisis of 2007-08 is widely regarded as the worst since the Great Depression of the 1930s. It became evident in September 2008, when major US banks were thrown into turmoil.

Its roots went back a decade. Property prices in the US were rising, and low interest rates fuelled demand for mortgages. Banks lent heavily, including to subprime borrowers, who would find it hard to meet their obligations. These loans were pooled, securitised and sold to hedge funds, banks and other financial institutions. When subprime borrowers began to default, the losses spread through economies around the world.

The crisis had an ethical side: irresponsible lending, little concern for the plight of borrowers and a lack of transparency. It also exposed failures of corporate governance and risk management at many systemically important financial institutions. Three groups stand out:

  • Mortgage brokers wanted business and a bigger loan book, and did not care about the creditworthiness of the borrowers they targeted.
  • Banks built their mortgage books aggressively, and sold pools of loans to other institutions knowing they were subprime.
  • Credit rating agencies, affected by conflicts of interest, gave biased ratings to risky mortgage-backed securities. Bonds rated triple A were downgraded to junk towards the end of the crisis.

Leading investment banks fell. Bear Stearns was taken over by JPMorgan Chase with help from the Federal Reserve, and Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy in September 2008. The crisis left a lasting question about the integrity and transparency of credit rating practices.

Taxmann.com | Research | FEMA, Banking & NBFC

3. Why did PMC Bank fail?

Punjab and Maharashtra Co-operative (PMC) Bank was a multi-state scheduled urban co-operative bank. It had 137 branches in seven states: Andhra Pradesh, Delhi, Goa, Gujarat, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra. The PMC Bank scam was one of India’s biggest bank frauds of 2019.

In September 2019, RBI began looking into the bank after a whistle-blower complained of fraudulent activities involving even its board. The complaint proved true. From the close of business on 23 September 2019, RBI placed the bank under all-inclusive directions, superseded its board and appointed an administrator. It cited “major financial irregularities”, failures of internal control and systems, and wrong or under-reporting of the bank’s exposures.

Those exposures were to one borrower group. The bank had used dummy accounts to hide loans to Housing Development and Infrastructure Ltd (HDIL), a Mumbai real estate company. About 73% of its loan book was tied to that one group.

At the time, RBI’s norms limited an urban co-operative bank’s exposure to 15% of its capital funds for a single borrower and 40% for a group. The Government told Parliament in November 2019 that PMC had falsified its regulatory returns, withholding information about HDIL so that it would appear to comply.

The concealment ran for years. In a letter to RBI, as reported in the press, the bank’s former managing director explained why the HDIL accounts had been reported as standard. Classifying them as NPAs, he wrote, would have hit the bank’s profits, drawn regulatory action and created reputational risk.

The book treats that reasoning as the heart of the case: concern for profit and reputation was put ahead of honest reporting and compliance. It also notes the gap between word and deed. The bank’s declared mission promised to serve customers with “concern, care and competence”.

Its verdict is ethical collapse. The irregularities came from unethical and irresponsible practices by the board and senior management, and middle and junior staff also compromised their integrity. Its lessons are plain:

  • special favours went to one customer, without assessing its ability to service the borrowings;
  • those in charge assumed nothing would change, and overlooked the risks;
  • the principle of trust was violated, because the board did not look after the customers who had trusted the bank with their deposits.

In January 2022, the Government sanctioned a scheme amalgamating PMC Bank with Unity Small Finance Bank, which took over its assets and liabilities, including deposits.

4. Why did Silicon Valley Bank collapse?

Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) was founded in 1983. A regional bank based in Silicon Valley, it was among the early banks to focus on banking for start-ups backed by venture capital, mostly technology companies. At the end of 2022, it had total assets of about US$209 billion.

During the pandemic, its tech clients raised large amounts of cash and kept it with the bank. SVB invested much of these deposits in long-term US Treasuries and agency mortgage-backed securities. When the Federal Reserve raised interest rates in 2022 to fight inflation, the value of those bonds fell.

Then venture funding began to dry up, and clients drew on their deposits. Much of SVB’s money was tied up in long-term investments, so it sold bonds at a significant loss. On 8 March 2023, it announced a US$1.8 billion loss on a sale of securities, and plans to raise capital.

Alarm spread quickly, helped by social media. On 9 March, depositors pulled more than US$40 billion from the bank. On 10 March, the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation closed SVB and appointed the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) as receiver.

On 26 March 2023, the FDIC announced that First-Citizens Bank & Trust Company would take over the deposits and loans of the bridge bank set up in SVB’s place. It estimated the cost to its Deposit Insurance Fund at about US$20 billion. At the time, SVB was the largest US bank failure since the 2008 financial crisis.

Ethics in Banking traces the collapse to a set of vulnerabilities:

  • a high proportion of uninsured deposits;
  • a large share of deposits invested in securities held to maturity;
  • a lack of diversification;
  • a rise in interest rates of a kind the US had not seen for decades, which led depositors to move money for better returns;
  • a classic bank run, as many customers withdrew their deposits at once for fear the bank was insolvent.

It calls SVB a classic case of asset-liability mismatch that turned into a solvency problem.

The Federal Reserve’s own review, published in April 2023, was critical. It found that SVB’s board and management had failed to manage their risks. Its supervisors had not fully appreciated the bank’s vulnerabilities as it grew, and did not act quickly enough when they did. When SVB failed, it had 31 unaddressed supervisory warnings on safety and soundness, triple the average for peer banks.

The book’s lesson is that strong, continuing regulation is not optional for the financial sector. But rules work only when banks follow them in substance as well as in form. Banking rests on trust because of a built-in mismatch: banks hold long-term assets such as loans, funded by deposits that can leave at short notice.

5. What was the LIBOR scandal?

LIBOR, the London Interbank Offered Rate, was the rate at which major London banks reported they could borrow from other banks. It served as the benchmark for countless other rates, on everything from credit cards and mortgages to loans between banks. It was also a measure of confidence: a bank that had to pay more to borrow looked weaker than its peers.

The rate was set in a simple way. Each morning, the banks on the panel submitted the rates at which they expected to borrow. The highest and lowest quarters of the submissions were discarded, the rest were averaged, and every bank’s submission was published.

On 27 June 2012, Barclays admitted misconduct and was fined more than US$450 million by UK and US authorities. The penalties were £59.5 million from the UK’s Financial Services Authority, US$200 million from the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and US$160 million from the US Department of Justice. The CFTC found that Barclays had made false reports on LIBOR and Euribor, sometimes daily, over four years from as early as 2005.

There were two motives. Traders asked the bank’s submitters for rates that would help their derivatives positions. And during the financial crisis, at the direction of senior managers, Barclays submitted artificially low rates to protect its reputation.

People inside the bank saw the problem. In 2007, an employee warned a supervisor by email that the bank was being seen to contribute “patently false rates” and was therefore “dishonest by definition”. The submissions continued.

Investigations soon widened to other big banks. LIBOR itself has since been phased out: the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority says its last settings were published on 30 September 2024.

Ethics in Banking uses the case to ask questions every banker should face. Who is hurt when a benchmark is rigged? What did senior executives owe to prevent the fraud? And who is responsible for the integrity of a practice like LIBOR?

6. What lessons do these failures hold for bankers?

Set side by side, the cases share a pattern: warning signs were visible before each collapse, and they were not acted on in time.

Case What went wrong Lesson
Enron Liabilities kept off the books; aggressive growth and diversification Accounting tricks cannot sustain growth; audit regularly and early
Global financial crisis Irresponsible lending, securitised subprime loans and conflicted ratings Lend on the ability to repay; guard against conflicts of interest
Satyam Fake cash and invoices; independent directors and auditors missed them Investigate small discrepancies; keep governance strong
PMC Bank About 73% of loans tied to one group, hidden in dummy accounts Grant no special favours; report exposures honestly
Silicon Valley Bank Deposits invested in long-term bonds; concentrated, largely uninsured deposits Match assets to liabilities; act on supervisory warnings
LIBOR False rate submissions to help trades and protect reputation Benchmarks need honest inputs; heed internal warnings

The same unit that covers SVB also suggests ways to make rules work in practice:

  • ethical behaviour is often a matter of judgement, so set internal guidelines and periodically appraise decisions against them;
  • officers should take decisions as if they held a fiduciary position;
  • keep pay, incentives and bonuses transparent, because most scams and frauds are the result of greed;
  • take every business decision with its long-term effect on the bank’s image, reputation and brand in mind.

In the end, it argues, there is no substitute for self-regulation. For boards, the message is that governance has to work in substance, not just in form. Directors should question large or unusual items, keep exposures within limits and act on warnings from whistle-blowers, auditors and supervisors alike.

7. Quick answers

What was the Satyam scam?

A corporate accounting fraud at Satyam Computer Services, a leading Indian IT company, which came to light in January 2009. The US SEC found that its revenue, income and cash had been overstated by more than US$1 billion over five years.

What happened at Enron?

Enron kept large liabilities off its books in special purpose vehicles backed by its own shares. When big borrowings fell due in late 2001, it could not repay them, and it filed for bankruptcy on 2 December 2001.

Why did PMC Bank fail?

It hid loans to one real estate group, HDIL, in dummy accounts, and about 73% of its loan book was tied to that group. RBI placed it under all-inclusive directions from 23 September 2019, citing major financial irregularities and failures of internal control.

Why did Silicon Valley Bank collapse?

It had invested much of its deposits in long-term bonds that lost value as US interest rates rose, and its deposits were concentrated and largely uninsured. After it announced a loss on a bond sale on 8 March 2023, depositors withdrew more than US$40 billion the next day, and it was closed on 10 March.

What was the LIBOR scandal?

Barclays and other banks submitted false rates to LIBOR, a benchmark behind loans and contracts worldwide. In June 2012, Barclays admitted misconduct and was fined more than US$450 million by UK and US authorities.

What warning signs do these cases share?

Rapid growth or diversification, heavy reliance on one borrower or one kind of depositor, and figures that do not add up, such as an unusually large cash balance. Internal warnings that go unheeded are another sign.

What is the main lesson for bank boards?

Governance must work in substance, not just in form. Boards should question large or unusual items, keep exposures within limits, and act on warnings from whistle-blowers, auditors and supervisors.


These cases are drawn from Ethics in Banking, the courseware of the Indian Institute of Banking & Finance (IIBF) for its Certificate Course in Ethics in Banking (2026 Edition, published by Taxmann). Unit 2 covers Enron, the global financial crisis, Satyam and PMC Bank. Unit 4 uses the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank to ask how effective regulation is, and the LIBOR scandal is a case for discussion in Unit 6.

For the rules behind these cases, Banking Acts and Rules, RBI’s circulars and notifications, and case laws are on Taxmann.com | Research, FEMA, Banking & Insurance.

Related reading: the SVB crisis in 10 simple points · the merger of PMC Bank with Unity Small Finance Bank · how effective independent directors are in corporate governance.

More in this series: ethics in banking: meaning, principles and challenges · business ethics in banking · PIDPI and whistleblowing in banks · white-collar crime and corruption in banking · conflict of interest in banks.

Stated as on 16 November 2026. PMC Bank was amalgamated with Unity Small Finance Bank on 25 January 2022, and LIBOR ceased after its last publication on 30 September 2024.

Disclaimer: The content/information published on the website is only for general information of the user and shall not be construed as legal advice. While the Taxmann has exercised reasonable efforts to ensure the veracity of information/content published, Taxmann shall be under no liability in any manner whatsoever for incorrect information, if any.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Everything on Tax and Corporate Laws of India

To subscribe to our weekly newsletter please log in/register on Taxmann.com

Author: Taxmann

Taxmann Publications has a dedicated in-house Research & Editorial Team. This team consists of a team of Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries, and Lawyers. This team works under the guidance and supervision of editor-in-chief Mr Rakesh Bhargava.

The Research and Editorial Team is responsible for developing reliable and accurate content for the readers. The team follows the six-sigma approach to achieve the benchmark of zero error in its publications and research platforms. The team ensures that the following publication guidelines are thoroughly followed while developing the content:

  • The statutory material is obtained only from the authorized and reliable sources
  • All the latest developments in the judicial and legislative fields are covered
  • Prepare the analytical write-ups on current, controversial, and important issues to help the readers to understand the concept and its implications
  • Every content published by Taxmann is complete, accurate and lucid
  • All evidence-based statements are supported with proper reference to Section, Circular No., Notification No. or citations
  • The golden rules of grammar, style and consistency are thoroughly followed
  • Font and size that's easy to read and remain consistent across all imprint and digital publications are applied