[Analysis] Swiss Challenge Method in IBC – How It Works in Resolution and Liquidation | Process Flow | Rulings
- Blog|Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code|
- 9 Min Read
How the Swiss challenge method works in a CIRP, a pre-pack and a liquidation sale, with the step-by-step flow, NCLAT and Supreme Court rulings and RBI rules.
- By Taxmann
- |
- Last Updated on 16 November, 2026

Table of Contents
- What is the Swiss challenge method?
- How does a Swiss challenge work, step by step?
- Where does the IBC framework use a Swiss challenge?
- When can a CIRP use a challenge mechanism?
- Does the challenge stop the CoC from negotiating further?
- How is the base plan put to a challenge in a pre-pack?
- Can a liquidator sell assets through a Swiss challenge?
- How do the RBI Directions use the Swiss challenge?
- Quick answers
1. What is the Swiss challenge method?
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI), in a Discussion Paper dated 27 August 2021, described it as a bidding process in which an original bidder makes an unsolicited bid. Once that bid is approved, the auctioneer invites counter-proposals and picks the best option, the original bid included. The original bidder usually gets the first right to match. If it matches the challenging proposal, it wins; if not, the challenger wins.
Kothari and Bansal describe a challenge mechanism as a common feature of auctions and bidding, aimed at better price discovery. The opening offer is the base bid in the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) framework, the anchor bid in the liquidation rulings and the base resolution plan in a pre-pack.
2. How does a Swiss challenge work, step by step?
Kothari and Bansal’s flowchart (Fig. 30.2) in Taxmann’s Law Relating to Insolvency & Bankruptcy sets out the usual steps. It is based on Para 93 of the RBI (Commercial Banks – Transfer and Distribution of Credit Risk) Directions, 2025:
- The prospective transferee submits a base bid.
- Counter-bids are invited publicly.
- The counter-bids are evaluated.
- If no counter-bid qualifies, the base bid wins.
- If qualifying counter-bids come in, the highest becomes the challenger bid.
- The base bidder is invited to match the challenger bid.
- If it matches or bids higher, its bid wins. If it does not, the challenger bid wins.
3. Where does the IBC framework use a Swiss challenge?
Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), the method appears in three settings: the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP), the pre-packaged insolvency resolution process (PPIRP) and liquidation sales. Who decides differs: in a CIRP the committee of creditors (CoC) chooses, in a pre-pack section 54K sets the triggers, and in liquidation the CoC now approves the manner of sale. A fourth, the creditor-initiated insolvency resolution process (CIIRP), awaits notification.
| Setting | Rule | Must there be a challenge? | Status on 30 September 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| CIRP | Regulation 39(1A)(b), CIRP Regulations | No. It may be used only if the request for resolution plans provides for it | In force from 30 September 2021 |
| PPIRP (pre-pack) | Section 54K(5) to (12) | Yes, if the CoC does not approve the base plan or it impairs operational creditors’ claims; rival plans are then invited, and the base plan competes head-to-head unless the CoC selects a rival plan that clears its margin | In force (Chapter IIIA, from 4 April 2021) |
| Liquidation sale | Section 35(1)(f); regulation 33, Liquidation Process Regulations | Case by case; appellate rulings show it used for private sales | CoC supervises liquidation under section 35(2), from 26 May 2026 |
| CIIRP | Regulation 17(3), draft CIIRP Regulations | The draft requires the CoC to use it | Chapter IV-A not yet notified; Regulations in draft |
| Banks selling stressed loans (outside the Code) | RBI Directions, 2025 | Yes, after bilateral talks where exposure is ₹100 crore or more, and where all inter-creditor agreement (ICA) signatories exit | Applies to commercial banks |
4. When can a CIRP use a challenge mechanism?
Only when the request for resolution plans (RFRP) provides for it. Regulation 39(1A) of the CIRP Regulations has been in force since 30 September 2021. If the RFRP so envisages, the resolution professional (RP) may allow one modification of a plan received, or use a challenge mechanism so that resolution applicants can improve their plans.
The provision came out of the IBBI’s 2021 Discussion Paper, which suggested the Swiss challenge to deal with delay in passing resolution plans. The paper noted that nothing expressly barred the method, but rulings had gone both ways. It was specifically ordered in Bank of Baroda v. Mandhana Industries Ltd. [C.P.(IB) No. 1399/MB/C-I/2017] and rejected in Saket Tex Dye Private Limited v. Kailash T. Shah [C.P. 1981(IB)/MB/2019] because the Regulations did not provide for it.
Using one option does not shut out the other. In Vizag Minerals & Logistics Pvt. Ltd. v. Ravi Shankar Devarakonda [Diary No. 27746 of 2023], the Supreme Court agreed with the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at Chennai that “The word ‘or’ in the said sub-regulation should be read as ‘in addition to’ and not ‘to the exclusion of’.”
Our CIRP explainer covers the earlier stages, and the rulings can be tracked in Taxmann.com Research’s IBC module.
5. Does the challenge stop the CoC from negotiating further?
No. In Vistra ITCL (India) Ltd. v. Torrent Investments Pvt. Ltd. [2023] 151 taxmann.com 174 (NCLAT – New Delhi), the NCLAT held that after the challenge mechanism under regulation 39(1A)(b) is complete, the CoC may still negotiate with one or other resolution applicants, or annul the process and issue a fresh RFRP. In its words, “Regulation 39(1A) cannot be read as a fetter on the powers of the CoC to discuss and deliberate”.
The limit in regulation 39(1A) is on the RP, not the CoC. In Sagar Stone Industries v. Sajjan Kumar Dokania [Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 524 of 2025], the NCLAT at New Delhi held that the CoC may ask for revised plans or negotiate with all resolution applicants, once or more.
The commentary lists this ruling among those upholding the CoC’s commercial wisdom. Its summary says the mechanism “is merely a value-maximisation tool and is not a mandatory requirement”. The CoC decides whether to adopt it, how to run it, and whether to modify or drop it.
A change is only proposed so far. An IBBI Discussion Paper dated 16 February 2026 suggests that the CoC also record its deliberations on the adequacy of market discovery, including any use of a challenge mechanism or re-invitation of plans.
6. How is the base plan put to a challenge in a pre-pack?
Through section 54K. A pre-pack, open only to micro, small and medium enterprises, starts with the corporate debtor’s own base resolution plan [section 5(2B)]. The commentary treats the base plan as facing a Swiss challenge once rival plans are invited, and its comparison of CIRP and PPIRP calls the selection a mandatory challenge mechanism.
Claims are impaired where the plan does not pay confirmed claims in full as per the RP’s updated list of claims [Explanation II to section 54K]. The contest runs as follows:
| Stage | What happens | Time limit or vote |
|---|---|---|
| Base plan | The corporate debtor submits it; the RP places it before the CoC [s. 54K(1)] | Within 2 days of commencement |
| First look | The CoC may allow a revision, and may approve it if operational creditors’ claims are not impaired [s. 54K(2), (4)] | 66% of voting shares [s. 54K(13)] |
| Invitation | Otherwise the RP invites rival plans [s. 54K(5)] | Within 21 days of commencement; at least 15 days to submit; no non-refundable deposit [reg. 43, PPIRP Regulations] |
| Rules | The invitation discloses the scoring basis, the margin to count as significantly better, the tick size and how to improve [s. 54K(7); Form P11] | Approved by the CoC |
| Selection | The RP presents the plans that meet section 30(2); the CoC evaluates them and selects one [s. 54K(8), (9)] | Scored on the disclosed basis |
| Challenge round | Unless the CoC finds the selected plan significantly better and selects it for approval, it competes with the base plan; with both scores disclosed, each side improves by at least one tick size until one stops [s. 54K(10), (11)] | 48 hours |
| Approval | The CoC votes on the higher-scoring plan; if it is not approved, the RP applies to end the PPIRP [s. 54K(12), (13)] | 66%; plan to the Adjudicating Authority (NCLT) within 90 days and PPIRP completed within 120 days of commencement [s. 54D] |
Before approving a plan, the CoC must also consider the order of priority under section 53(1) [s. 54K(13)], which our post on the waterfall mechanism under section 53 explains. Our PPIRP explainer covers the wider process, and Taxmann.com Learning lists a webinar on the pre-packaged insolvency resolution process.
7. Can a liquidator sell assets through a Swiss challenge?
Yes, within the sale rules. Section 35(1)(f) lets the liquidator sell by public auction or private contract. Under regulation 33 of the Liquidation Process Regulations, sale is ordinarily by auction, and a private sale generally needs the NCLT’s permission.
In Orissa Alloy Steel Pvt. Ltd. v. S.M. Steels & Power Ltd. [2025] 180 taxmann.com 278 (NCLAT – New Delhi), the liquidator ran a Swiss challenge after nine failed auctions and picked an anchor bidder. The NCLAT held that a private sale under regulation 33(2)(d) needs the NCLT’s prior permission, and this process had started before that approval. It rejected the charge of collusion, though, for want of concrete evidence; the Stakeholder Consultation Committee had approved the process by an overwhelming majority.
In State Bank of India v. Bhuvee Stenovate Pvt. Ltd. [Comp. App. (AT) (Insolvency) No. 1013 of 2022], several auctions had failed and Laser Solar LLP made the highest offer before the NCLT, an offer the liquidator had already rejected as substantially lower than the last reserve price. The NCLAT set aside the NCLT’s order approving the private sale. The NCLT cannot itself run a bidding process or confirm a private sale, as the power of sale under regulation 33 lies with the liquidator, and a private sale must be transparent and open to all interested buyers. The liquidator was directed to run a Swiss challenge with Laser Solar LLP’s offer as the anchor bid.
Since 26 May 2026, the substituted section 35(2) makes the CoC supervise the liquidation. Under regulation 8(5), as amended in 2026, sale matters under regulation 32, including the manner of sale, need prior CoC approval by a 66% vote. The authors expect rulings that uphold the CoC’s commercial wisdom to matter in liquidation sales too. See also our explainer on the liquidator under IBC.
8. How do the RBI Directions use the Swiss challenge?
In a CIRP, the CoC chooses whether to use the method. For banks transferring stressed loans, the RBI makes it compulsory in two cases. Under the RBI (Commercial Banks – Transfer and Distribution of Credit Risk) Directions, 2025, a bilaterally negotiated sale of stressed assets must be followed by a Swiss challenge auction if the lenders’ aggregate exposure (including investment exposure) to the borrower is ₹100 crore or more. Below that, the bank’s board-approved policy applies, and it may include the method. Under the Reserve Bank of India (Commercial Banks – Resolution of Stressed Assets) Directions, 2025, the method is mandatory, whatever the exposure, when all ICA signatories exit the stressed loan.
The board-approved policy should also specify when the bank may opt for the method, for instance based on a tolerance limit for the haircut in the base bid. It should also fix the minimum mark-up a challenger bid needs over the base bid. That mark-up cannot be less than 5% or more than 15% of the base bid. For a transfer made as a resolution plan with ICA approval, the minimum mark-up needs the approval of signatories holding 75% of total outstanding credit facilities by value and 60% of signatories by number.
9. Quick answers
Is a Swiss challenge compulsory in every CIRP?
No. Regulation 39(1A) of the CIRP Regulations allows a challenge mechanism only if the request for resolution plans provides for it. The NCLAT treats the choice to adopt, modify or drop it as the committee of creditors’ commercial wisdom.
Can a resolution plan be modified once and still face a challenge mechanism?
Yes. The Supreme Court agreed with the NCLAT that the two options in regulation 39(1A) are not exclusive. If the request for resolution plans provides for it, the resolution professional may allow one modification of a plan, and the committee of creditors may still adopt a challenge mechanism.
When must a pre-pack base plan compete with other plans?
Under section 54K(5), when the committee of creditors does not approve the base resolution plan or it impairs operational creditors’ claims. Unless the committee selects a rival plan that clears its margin, the two improve in tick-size steps within 48 hours.
Can the NCLT run its own auction during liquidation?
No. The NCLAT has held that the power of sale under regulation 33 of the Liquidation Process Regulations lies with the liquidator, so the NCLT cannot itself run a bidding process or confirm a private sale. It directed a Swiss challenge instead.
What mark-up must a challenger bid carry under the RBI Directions?
A bank’s board-approved policy fixes the minimum mark-up over the base bid, which cannot be less than 5% or more than 15%. The mark-up is the difference between the two bids, expressed as a percentage of the base bid. Where the transfer is a resolution plan approved by inter-creditor agreement signatories, they decide the minimum mark-up instead.
This analysis draws on the commentary on sections 30, 35 and 54K in Taxmann’s Law Relating to Insolvency & Bankruptcy by Vinod Kothari and Sikha Bansal (2nd Edition, two volumes): a section-wise commentary on the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 with a flowchart of the steps in a Swiss challenge (Fig. 30.2), with the law stated as on 30th September 2026.
The text of the Code, the Rules and Regulations, the notifications and the rulings cited above are available in the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code module of Taxmann.com Research.
Related reading: Pre-packaged insolvency resolution process (PPIRP) · Liquidator under IBC.
Disclaimer: The content/information published on the website is only for general information of the user and shall not be construed as legal advice. While the Taxmann has exercised reasonable efforts to ensure the veracity of information/content published, Taxmann shall be under no liability in any manner whatsoever for incorrect information, if any.

Taxmann Publications has a dedicated in-house Research & Editorial Team. This team consists of a team of Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries, and Lawyers. This team works under the guidance and supervision of editor-in-chief Mr Rakesh Bhargava.
The Research and Editorial Team is responsible for developing reliable and accurate content for the readers. The team follows the six-sigma approach to achieve the benchmark of zero error in its publications and research platforms. The team ensures that the following publication guidelines are thoroughly followed while developing the content:
- The statutory material is obtained only from the authorized and reliable sources
- All the latest developments in the judicial and legislative fields are covered
- Prepare the analytical write-ups on current, controversial, and important issues to help the readers to understand the concept and its implications
- Every content published by Taxmann is complete, accurate and lucid
- All evidence-based statements are supported with proper reference to Section, Circular No., Notification No. or citations
- The golden rules of grammar, style and consistency are thoroughly followed
- Font and size that’s easy to read and remain consistent across all imprint and digital publications are applied


CA | CS | CMA