Revenue Recognition in Bill-and-Hold Arrangements under Ind AS

1. Concept of Performance Obligation

Revenue recognition under Ind AS is closely tied to the concept of performance obligations. A performance obligation is essentially a promise made by an entity in a contract to deliver a distinct good or service to the customer. Revenue can only be recognized once this obligation has been satisfied, which occurs when control of the promised goods or services is transferred to the customer. Importantly, control is a broader concept than physical possession—it refers to the customer’s ability to direct the use of the asset and obtain substantially all of its benefits.

2. Understanding Bill-and-Hold Arrangements

A Bill-and-Hold arrangement arises when the seller has invoiced the customer, but at the customer’s request, the delivery of goods is deferred to a later date. In such cases, the goods remain in the seller’s warehouse even though ownership and invoicing may have already occurred. These situations often create ambiguity in determining whether the transfer of control has happened and, consequently, when revenue can be recognized under the Ind AS framework.

3. Key Issues in Revenue Recognition

The core issue in Bill-and-Hold arrangements is whether the company can recognize revenue immediately upon raising the invoice and holding the goods, or whether revenue recognition should be postponed until the goods are physically delivered. Simply invoicing the customer does not automatically mean that control has been transferred. Instead, the entity must assess whether the customer has obtained the ability to control the goods, even while they are physically stored with the seller.

4. Conditions for Recognition under Ind AS

Ind AS provides specific criteria that must be met before revenue can be recognised in a Bill-and-Hold arrangement. These include:

• The customer must have requested the delayed delivery and provided valid reasons.
• The goods must be separately identified and ready for physical transfer.
• The seller must not have the ability to use the goods or redirect them to another customer.
• The customer must have accepted the arrangement and taken on the risks and rewards of ownership.

5. Practical Implications for Companies

For companies, careful documentation and compliance are crucial in such cases. If the above conditions are not fully met, recognizing revenue prematurely could result in misstatements in financial statements and potential regulatory issues. Therefore, entities must evaluate each arrangement carefully, ensure contractual clarity, and maintain robust evidence that control has indeed passed to the customer before revenue is recorded.

Click Here To Read The Full Story