Notification is Needed to Apply MFN Clause; No Benefit If Country Joins OECD Post Signing of First Treaty | SC

  • Blog|News|International Tax|
  • 2 Min Read
  • By Taxmann
  • |
  • Last Updated on 21 October, 2023

MFN Clause

Case Details: Assessing Officer v. Nestle SA - [2023] 155 taxmann.com 384 (SC)

Judiciary and Counsel Details

    • S. Ravindra Bhat, J.
    • Additional Solicitor General, Shri N. Venkatraman, for the Appellant.
    • Poros Kaka, P. Chidambaram, S. Ganesh & Percy Pardiwala, learned senior counsel; Lovkesh Sawhney and Mukesh Bhutani, learned counsel, for the Respondent.

Facts of the Case

The issue before the Supreme Court was:

“Can the MFN clause be invoked when India’s DTAA partner was not an OECD member when the agreement was made? And is the MFN clause automatic or requires a notification to come into effect?”

Supreme Court Held

The Supreme Court held as under:

The word ‘is’ appearing in Clause IV(2) of the India-Netherlands DTAA need to be interpreted correctly. The clause is quoted below:

“If after the signature of this convention under any Convention or Agreement between India and a third State which is a member of the OECD, India should…………….”

The expression “is” has a present signification and derives meaning from the context. The conclusion is that when a third-party country enters into DTAA with India, it should be a member of the OECD, for the earlier treaty beneficiary to claim parity.

The treaty practices of Switzerland, Netherlands, and France are influenced by their unique constitutional and legal systems. In India, when a third state joins the OECD after signing a Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA), India must communicate and accept the beneficial effect through a notification under Section 90, with prior negotiation and communication.

Therefore, the essential requirement of a notification under Section 90 of the consequences of the trigger (or causative) event cannot be undermined.

If a DTAA or Protocol provision with one nation mandates equal treatment for a specific matter, even after another nation (part of OECD) receives preferential treatment. In that case, it doesn’t automatically apply the same benefit to the DTAA of the first nation that has an agreement with India. In this case, the terms of the earlier DTAA need a separate amendment through a notification under Section 90.

Accordingly, for a court, authority, or tribunal to enforce a DTAA or any protocol that alters existing legal provisions, a notification under Section 90(1) is essential and obligatory.

Disclaimer: The content/information published on the website is only for general information of the user and shall not be construed as legal advice. While the Taxmann has exercised reasonable efforts to ensure the veracity of information/content published, Taxmann shall be under no liability in any manner whatsoever for incorrect information, if any.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Everything on Tax and Corporate Laws of India

To subscribe to our weekly newsletter please log in/register on Taxmann.com

Author: Taxmann

Taxmann Publications has a dedicated in-house Research & Editorial Team. This team consists of a team of Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries, and Lawyers. This team works under the guidance and supervision of editor-in-chief Mr Rakesh Bhargava.

The Research and Editorial Team is responsible for developing reliable and accurate content for the readers. The team follows the six-sigma approach to achieve the benchmark of zero error in its publications and research platforms. The team ensures that the following publication guidelines are thoroughly followed while developing the content:

  • The statutory material is obtained only from the authorized and reliable sources
  • All the latest developments in the judicial and legislative fields are covered
  • Prepare the analytical write-ups on current, controversial, and important issues to help the readers to understand the concept and its implications
  • Every content published by Taxmann is complete, accurate and lucid
  • All evidence-based statements are supported with proper reference to Section, Circular No., Notification No. or citations
  • The golden rules of grammar, style and consistency are thoroughly followed
  • Font and size that's easy to read and remain consistent across all imprint and digital publications are applied