1. No Exempt Income, No Disallowance:

Taxpayers and the Department are often at loggerheads on the matter of disallowance of an expense under Section 14A even if a no tax-free income is generated during the year. CBDT  has clarified that all expenses pertaining to an exempted income will be disallowed, notwithstanding the fact that no such income has been earned during the financial year. However, various courts have held that Section 14A disallowance couldn’t kick in when there is no exempted income earned by assesse.

2. No Disallowance from Dividend Income:

Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) is the tax paid by a domestic company in respect of the dividend paid by the company to its shareholders. Dividend is considered as a tax free income to a shareholder, even though it has actually suffered the economic taxation. In other words, even after the dividend income has been subjected to the dividend distribution tax yet it is categorized as an exempted income. Therefore, it is suggested that no such disallowance should be invoked under Section 14A for the expenses incurred in respect of the investments which are earning dividend income for the taxpayers. Dividend income is already taxed at the rate of 20.357% so any further disallowance would be perverse and unreasonable for the investors.  

You can also read: Some Income Tax rules need to be updated

3. No Disallowance if MAT is applicable:

Minimum Alternative Tax (MAT) is the minimum amount of income-tax that every company is required to pay during a financial year. It is levied on the book profit which is computed after making prescribed adjustments in the net profit as reported in the financial statement. As of now, the provisions of MAT do not prescribe the adjustments for any disallowance made under Section 14A, but the tax officers often add back the disallowance under section 14A while computing the book profits. The Special Bench of Delhi Tribunal in the case of ACIT v. Vireet Investment (P.) Ltd. [2017] 82 taxmann.com 415 (Delhi – Trib.) (SB) held that while computing book profit under Section 115JB, provisions of Section 14A can’t be imported as any amount of expenditure computed by applying Rule 8D is an artificial or notional expenditure that is not debited in the profit and loss account. Therefore, it can’t be added back to compute the book profit. Hence, it is recommended that an amendment should be made to clarify that any expenditure disallowed under Section 14A shall not be added back while computing the book profit.

4. Disallowance for the Depreciation of Assets:

As we already know that section 14A disallows the specific and general expenses incurred by the taxpayers to earn an exempted income. Now, the matter or contention is if these attributed expenses also cover the depreciation of the fixed assets, for instance computers, office appliances, etc. that has been used in the process of earning the exempt income. In Hoshang D. Nanavati v. ACIT [2012] 25 taxmann.com 141 (Mum.-Trib.), it was held that the disallowance under Section 14A cannot cover depreciation in, as-much-as what is disallowed under section14A, is only expenditure and not allowance. Depreciation is in the nature of allowance and, thus it cannot be the subject matter of disallowance of an expense under section14A. An amendment can be suggested to Section 14A for plugging in this gap by overcoming the above judicial precedents.

Conclusion:

Also Read:

• Interim Budget 2019 Expectations

• Budget 2019-20 Highlights

• Interim Budget 2019: How to pay zero tax for salary upto 10 lakhs

• Budget 2019-20 – The Complete Tax Table for Proposed for Resident individuals

• FAQs on Union Budget 2018

• Budget Expectations 2018: Time to relook at ICDS Provisions

• India’s Union Budget: 14 Facts